A Florida plastic surgeon has been sentenced to death for murdering an attorney inside a law office bathroom before allegedly transporting his body to a remote area near the Everglades and disposing of it in a dumpster. More than three years later, the victim’s remains have never been found.
Dr. Tomasz Kosowski, 47, learned his fate Friday, November 20, after a judge determined that his carefully planned killing of attorney Steven Cozzi, 41, warranted the death penalty.
The case stunned investigators not only because of the elaborate planning involved but also because Kosowski managed to make his victim’s body disappear without a trace.
The murder occurred March 21, 2023, at a law firm in Largo, Florida, where Cozzi worked.
According to prosecutors, Kosowski had become increasingly angry over a bitter legal dispute involving a medical practice that he claimed owed him thousands of dollars in unpaid billings and had damaged his professional reputation.
Cozzi represented defendants in that lawsuit.
On the morning of the murder, the two men participated in a conference call concerning the ongoing litigation.
But investigators say Kosowski wasn’t calling from his office or home.
Instead, he was sitting in a Toyota pickup truck parked outside the law firm, where prosecutors allege he had already prepared everything needed to carry out the killing.
Among the items investigators said he brought were garbage bags, a syringe containing a paralyzing medication and equipment for transporting a body.
Shortly after the call ended, Cozzi disappeared.
His wallet, keys and cellphone were still sitting on his desk, and an unfinished work document remained open on his computer.
His husband, Michael Montgomery, became increasingly worried when he couldn’t reach him.
What initially appeared to be a mysterious disappearance soon developed into a murder investigation.
Detectives discovered blood and other forensic evidence inside the law firm’s bathroom, suggesting that Cozzi had been attacked there.
Investigators later found additional traces of his blood and DNA in the garage of Kosowski’s home.
Surveillance footage and cellphone records helped detectives reconstruct the surgeon’s movements after Cozzi vanished.
According to prosecutors, Kosowski transported the attorney’s body across Florida to a remote stretch of the Tamiami Trail, a highway running through the Everglades west of Miami.
Investigators believe he dumped the remains into a commercial trash container.
The dumpster was subsequently emptied by a garbage truck, whose driver later recalled an unusually foul odor coming from that particular collection stop.
Authorities traced the garbage route to a landfill in Collier County, but their efforts to recover Cozzi’s remains were unsuccessful.
Investigators explained that the landfill’s waste-compaction operations made locating a body extremely difficult.
Cozzi has never been found.
The evidence against Kosowski became even more disturbing when detectives searched his belongings and residence.
According to court documents, investigators discovered approximately $280,000 in cash, masks, duct tape, firearms, law enforcement patches and a ballistic vest marked with the letters “EMS.”
They also recovered a vial of succinylcholine, a powerful medication that causes temporary muscle paralysis, and found roughly 200 guns at his home.
Prosecutors argued that the collection of equipment, combined with Kosowski’s movements and the forensic evidence, demonstrated an extraordinary level of planning.
The surgeon was ultimately charged with first-degree murder.
His trial took an unusual turn when he dismissed his attorneys, waived his right to a jury and chose to represent himself.
Rather than presenting witnesses or mounting a traditional defense, Kosowski argued that prosecutors had failed to prove their case, emphasizing that investigators had never recovered Cozzi’s body.
But Pinellas County Circuit Judge Joseph Bulone rejected that argument.
On September 23, 2026, Bulone found Kosowski guilty of first-degree murder, determining that the evidence established his responsibility for Cozzi’s death despite the absence of a body.
The judge then faced a difficult decision: sentence Kosowski to life in prison without parole or impose the death penalty.
During the penalty proceedings, Kosowski declined to present evidence asking the court for leniency.
Special counsel appointed by the court nevertheless highlighted several mitigating circumstances, including the surgeon’s lack of a prior criminal record and his professional accomplishments.
Kosowski had graduated from Dartmouth’s medical school and specialized in reconstructive breast surgery.
However, Judge Bulone determined that those factors were outweighed by the seriousness of the crime.
In particular, he concluded that the murder had been committed in a calculated and premeditated manner.
The judge also found that financial gain was an aggravating factor.
During Friday’s sentencing hearing, Bulone delivered a stark statement explaining his decision.
“The court concludes that the defendant, under the laws of the State of Florida, has forfeited his right to live,” he said.
Kosowski was sentenced to death.
The public defender’s office was subsequently appointed to represent him during the appeals process.
For Cozzi’s loved ones, the sentencing brought a measure of justice after more than three years of uncertainty.
But one heartbreaking reality remains unchanged.
Despite the extensive investigation, the forensic evidence and the murder conviction, Cozzi’s body has never been recovered, leaving his husband and family without the opportunity to lay him to rest.
Discover more from
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

